I'm now finishing JUST LIKE THAT by Gary D. Schmidt, and all I can say is Newbery Newbery Newbery. (Actually, most books I like in this same way take Newbery Honors, but that counts.)
If you can forgive him for what he does on p. 2, the book is well worth the ride. Wonderful characters, voice like no other, harrowing and beautiful scenes, suspense, laugh-out-loud lines, and for Boomers, a good dose of nostalgia since it's set in 1968. As someone who returns probably around 70% of what I check out from the library either unread or mostly skimmed, I can't recommend this one enough.