SCBWI's Blueboard - A Message & Chat Board

Genres & Age Categories => Magazines & Ezines => Topic started by: Orchid on April 28, 2017, 12:42 PM

Title: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Orchid on April 28, 2017, 12:42 PM
I feel this is bizarre. I submitted a fiction story to Babybug and I got an email today stating that my submittable status changed. When I looked at it, the status on my story was 'decline'. There is no form R, not even a word. Just nothing. Does this happen? This story went into "In-progress" yesterday after a week since I submitted. I am wondering that when Cricket hates something so much, they don't even bother to send a form reject?  :sigh  :sadcry
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Ev on April 28, 2017, 01:15 PM
I don't know the situation, Orchid, but if I had to guess, I'd say maybe Babybug has gotten hugely swamped with subs like Hello, and they're just trying to get back to folks in the most expedient manner possible. It sounds like Submittable can be automated to send an email if the status changes. And the first readers consider finding a 'Decline' on Submittable to be no different than getting a form rejection.

I don't think it's any reflection on the quality of your submission. But I'm sending you extra hugs.  :hug Any kind of reject is hard.
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Orchid on April 28, 2017, 04:22 PM
Thanks Ev! I think I had hopes built up on this one specifically after Highlights sent me a 'personal reject' on the same story saying that it was 'well done'. I think I learnt today how much this business is subjective. Onto the next one, I guess!
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Dianna Winget on April 28, 2017, 04:46 PM
Hi Orchid. Just wanted to add that there are many reasons for rejection that have absolutely nothing to do with the quality of your sub. Maybe they just purchased something similar, or they really need stories that feature a boy instead of a girl, or maybe a chicken instead of a dog  :grin3 This industry is not only subjective, but is also a real heartbreaker at times. It's important not to take rejection personally. Just dust off that "well-written" story and find it a new home.  :horse2
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Dionna on April 29, 2017, 01:11 PM
Hi Orchid!
Did you received a form  rejection email? I have from Cricket Media, and then the status changed to declined. Don’t take it personal if you didn't get personal feedback. That happens to all of us. If they declined without sending you a form letter , my guess is that an intern reading the huge electronic slush pile forgot to send it.  Focus on your Highlights personal reply. That is a super compliment!
Bestest!
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Debbie Vilardi on April 30, 2017, 09:24 PM
Have you checked all your spam filters? Sometimes it was sent and missed.

No reply meaning no thanks is common in the industry, so this may be a form of that, but usually companies let us all know if they're making that kind of switch by posting it someplace.
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Orchid on May 01, 2017, 09:45 AM
Thanks for all the positive words :)

Well, I definitely did not get the email because I checked all my mail folders. Submittable keeps a copy of the form letter or any communication that was sent out as well and there's nothing there either! For now, I am trying to think of ways how I can repackage the story to send it to a different magazine.
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Trine on May 04, 2017, 07:20 PM
I must admit that "no reply means no thanks" is quite discouraging  to me.
I think a company can at least reply with a no thank you.  :cry2
Sigh...
Title: Re: Cricket - no form R, a straight decline on Submittable status?!
Post by: Debbie Vilardi on May 08, 2017, 11:12 AM
I must admit that "no reply means no thanks" is quite discouraging  to me.
I think a company can at least reply with a no thank you.  :cry2
Sigh...

Me too. I keep hoping a positive reply will appear unless I've been given a specific date.  It feels both cruel and impolite. In truth it is dehumanizing because it doesn't acknowledge the humanness of the sender. But it is also the way of the world, not just in publishing.