[DebraG Posts: 51 Status: Offline WWW]

Hi.  My question is how do you write about scary stuff without creating a new fear in a child? 

For example, you write about scary things that live in the dark when mom turns out the light for bed.  Assume the book maybe is fun and light-hearted, not scary.  Before the book was read to the child, he had no fear of the dark.  He had no idea there was even such a thing as being afraid of the dark.  Now, your book has opened his mind to the thought.   He is now scared of the dark.

My initial thoughts are the adults in the child's life are responsible for monitoring (1) what materials are read to the child and (2) what ideas and concepts the child is exposed to.    Therefore, if I want to write about something that involves a stereotypical childhood fear, then I shouldn't be afraid to do so.

Your thoughts?

[MysteryRobin Posts: 693 Status: Offline]

My thoughts are that yes, the grownups are in charge of appropriate reading material. Books are a good way to experience fear and conquer it, and as an author, I certainly wouldn't let that stop me. Some kids are too young or too sensitive for certain topics, but some kids *need* those topics and a healthy way to talk about them and process them and ultimately conquer them.
GK Chesterton said "Fairy tales do not tell children the dragons exist. Children already know that dragons exist. Fairy tales tell children the dragons can be killed."

[Franzilla Posts: 1,000 Status: Offline Gah! WWW]

Exactly what MysteryRobin said. My daughter scares incredibly easily (at Winnie the Pooh, for example) and so I know not to expose her to certain books. The only caveat I'd add is that it's up to the author/editor/publisher to make sure the cover and/or title/blurb make it clear what the book is intended to be. I read one book recently about 'the new puppy' (not giving the proper title away) and suddenly two thirds in a robber appeared in the story. He wanted to rob the house while everyone slept! I had to change the story as I read and try and explain the strange man away...

[Bigfoot Posts: 35 Status: Offline WWW]

I don't think we should spend too much energy worrying about triggering new fears in our readers. Childhood fears can develop in unexpected ways and about unexpected things. We'd never get any writing done if we dwelled on the possibility of a kid reacting negatively to our work.

[Vijaya Posts: 6,967 Status: Offline Encourage WWW]

Do not worry. Write what you want ... and let the parents be the judge of what is appropriate for their child.
Vijaya

[dewsanddamps Posts: 2,151 Status: Online]

I love MysteryRobin's G.K. Chesterton quote--always been a favorite.   :

When our daughter was in preschool, she used to talk about the "Big Bad Boys." These were the four year olds, who would line a hallway through which she had to walk at lunchtime. One day she asked me to tell her a story about the Big Bad Boys, and after that I told one almost nightly for several years. And you know, after I started telling the stories, she still didn't like the BBBs, but she stopped being afraid of them. They had been thwarted, night after night, often in comical ways.

I think the only thing to avoid is a scene that's much scarier than the rest of the book.

[DebraG Posts: 51 Status: Offline WWW]

Thank you for your helpful responses!

[HDWestlund Posts: 1,001 Status: Offline writer and bookseller]

As a bookseller, I am going to say this: Write what you want. It'll have it's audience. The parents are very selective when choosing books for that age group, for all the reasons mentioned above. And you would be surprised by things I get asked for. For a ridiculous exaggeration of the questions I get, "Do you have a book about friendly snails? My child is afraid of snails, and I'd like her to see that snails are people, too." And the parents who have kids who are afraid of the dark love having books that explore that issue. The parents with children who easily develop new fears avoid those books.

And in a side note, I apparently helped my niece get over her fear of snakes by accident. I sent her a brightly colored, beautiful picture book that was illustrated by David Diaz for Christmas one year. There is a roadrunner who conquers a snake in it--and my niece found that very comforting. (If I'd known she was afraid of snakes, I never would have sent the book!)

Holly

[CarrieF Posts: 201 Status: Offline WWW]

Ditto what has been said above. You should write what calls you. As a parents, there are definitely some topics I have avoided -- such as fear of the dark (my son never was, so why cause trouble?). But that shouldn't stop you from writing your story.

[HaroldU Posts: 763 Status: Offline WWW]

I am just jumping in to agree with what others have said. Don't censor yourself. Kids of all ages, even the youngest, are more complex than we know--and stronger than we know.

[dinalapomy101 Posts: 1,835 Status: Offline Happy writing to all! WWW]

I don't disagree with anything said here, but when I work in the Children's Room at the library, two question I get often are:
1. picture books about starting school that do not depict a scared child - only an excited one
2. picture books about moving that do not depict a scared child - only an excited one

In these cases, the parents are deciding what their child can handle, which is great! These topics seem to be big ones without "scaring" the child more.

[Just Jodi Posts: 368 Status: Offline Children's books are hard-bound hugs! WWW]

Totally agree with the "write what's in your heart" thing...love how Harold put it.

But as far as that initial fairy tale quote, I just had to jump in here in:  :dragon:

No one needs to kill any dragons...they're perfectly happy living in perfect sandcastles... 

Hugs, Jodi  :love3:

[DebraG Posts: 51 Status: Offline WWW]

How timely and on point!

http://www.mariondanebauer.com/blog/2012/10/when-is-scary-too-delicious/

[Anthony Posts: 67 Status: Offline You know, for kids! WWW]

That's a good article Debra. I like the distinction it makes between books and movies, too.

[Robertvs Posts: 54 Status: Offline 1 <3 PB WWW]

I was scared of THERE'S A WOCKET IN MY POCKET because of some of the creatures that lived in dark places, hidden under or in things, or were too fast to be seen... however this was just one element of the story and overall I liked the story even though some parts scared me.

If I was writing something scary, I would keep it scary but add some comfort or reassurance to it. More important than having fear would be how the fear is used.

On a related note, here are some kid movies:
-a runaway son grows up thinking he has caused the death of his father = Lion King
-a widow tries to help her sick son and learns about animal experimentation = Secret of Nimh
...now these might not be exactly PB-audience age, but they could be labelled kid movies and they certainly didn't shy away from dark themes. They used them to add to the story.